NL
Insuring a Tesla: why premiums are high, and 8 ways to pay less in the US and UK4 min

Insuring a Tesla: why premiums are high, and 8 ways to pay less in the US and UK

Tips ·

Teslas are often expensive to insure. Here is why, what Tesla's own driving-score insurance offers in the US, and practical steps that lower the premium on both sides of the Atlantic.

Many new Tesla owners get a surprise when the first insurance quote arrives. Teslas regularly cost more to insure than comparable petrol cars, and quotes for the same car can differ by hundreds a year. This guide explains why, and what you can do about it.

What owners actually pay

  • United States: according to quote data from comparison site Insurify, updated in October 2026, full coverage averages about $396 a month for a Model Y and about $441 for a Model 3.
  • United Kingdom: the Model Y sits in insurance groups 34 to 50 depending on the version, according to insurer Zego. Several groups were lowered in late 2025 and early 2026, so older comparison sites may still show higher ones. Zego's estimates for an experienced 35-year-old driver range from about £650 to £950 a year for the Standard Model Y to £1,400 or more for the Performance.

These are averages and estimates. Your age, postcode or ZIP code, mileage, claims history and parking all move the number a lot.

Why Teslas cost more to insure

  • Repair costs: aluminium body parts, cameras and sensors that need recalibrating after even small front-end damage, and a limited number of approved body shops.
  • Battery risk: the battery is a large share of the car's value, so serious damage near it can turn a repair into a write-off.
  • Price and performance: a high list price and fast acceleration push a car into higher risk groups.

There is some good news. Thatcham Research, which advises UK insurers on repair costs, studied Model Y crash repairs for two years. It found that repairing the Model Y's single-piece cast rear was nearly $3,000 cheaper than similar damage to the multi-panel Model 3, and that bolt-on replacement parts make small repairs simpler. Such findings feed into insurance group ratings over time.

Tesla Insurance: a US-only option

Tesla sells its own insurance in 15 US states: Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Minnesota, Nevada, Ohio, Oregon, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and Virginia. Tesla filed to add Washington from September 1, 2026; check the Tesla app to see if it is live where you are. You buy and manage the policy in the Tesla app.

Outside California, the monthly premium follows your Safety Score, which the car calculates from your driving. According to Insurify, the score drops for things like following too closely, speeding above 85 mph, driving between 10 p.m. and 4 a.m. and forced Autopilot disengagements. With Safety Score 3.0, miles driven with FSD (Supervised) count as a perfect 100, and drivers who use FSD for more than half their monthly miles can typically get about 10% off key parts of the policy. California does not allow real-time driving data to set the price.

Tesla's own insurance is not always the cheapest. Careful drivers can save; drivers who brake hard or drive late at night may pay more than with a regular insurer. In Europe and the UK, Tesla does not offer this driving-score product, so owners use regular insurers.

8 ways to pay less

  • 1. Compare widely. Zego found quotes for identical UK cover can differ by £400 to £800. Get at least four quotes, including from specialist EV insurers.
  • 2. Quote early. In the UK, quotes taken around three weeks before renewal tend to be cheaper than last-minute ones.
  • 3. Choose the trim with care. The Standard and Long Range rear-wheel-drive versions sit in much lower groups than the Performance.
  • 4. Raise your excess or deductible, but only to an amount you could actually pay after a claim.
  • 5. Be accurate about mileage and parking. Underestimating can void your cover when you need it.
  • 6. Pay annually if you can. Monthly payments often include interest.
  • 7. Consider telematics. Tesla Insurance in the US, or a black-box policy elsewhere, can reward smooth driving, especially for younger drivers.
  • 8. Check the repair terms. Ask whether the policy uses Tesla-approved body shops and genuine parts, and whether it covers the charging cable and wall box.

What to watch

Whether Tesla Insurance reaches more US states, and whether repair-friendly designs like the Model Y's cast parts keep pushing insurance groups down in the UK and Europe.

Sources (4)
11 kW

A 22 kW charger won't charge your Tesla any faster

Most Tesla models charge at home at up to 11 kW AC.

Read why →
4 min

Tesla warranty explained: what is covered in the US, UK and Europe, from the battery to used cars

Four years for the car, eight for the battery, and different mileage limits on each side of the Atlantic. A plain guide to Tesla's warranties, the 70% battery promise, used-car cover and your legal rights in Europe.

3 min

Tesla maintenance schedule: what servicing your Tesla really needs, and how often

No oil changes and no mandatory annual service, but tyres, filters, brake fluid and brakes still need attention. Tesla's recommended intervals for Model 3, Model Y, Model S and Model X, in plain language.

4 min

How to check your Tesla's battery health: the built-in test, what the result means and how to slow degradation

Teslas can now measure their own battery health. A step-by-step guide to running the test, reading the percentage, and the charging habits Tesla recommends to keep your battery healthy.

3 min

Tesla tyres explained: T markings, noise foam, rotation and winter rules in Europe

Electric cars are hard on tyres. What the T0 marking on a Tesla tyre means, how often to rotate, why EVs wear tyres faster, and the winter tyre rules if you drive to the Alps.

4 min

Insuring a Tesla: why premiums are high, and 8 ways to pay less in the US and UK

Teslas are often expensive to insure. Here is why, what Tesla's own driving-score insurance offers in the US, and practical steps that lower the premium on both sides of the Atlantic.

2 min

Buying a used Cybertruck: a checklist before you sign

Used Cybertruck prices have dropped as new prices were cut. Here is how to pick the right version, check the recall history and inspect the stainless-steel body.

2 min

Tesla in winter: 9 practical tips to keep your range up when it gets cold

Cold weather costs every electric car range. With the right settings, you can limit the loss and charge faster. Here is what actually works in a Tesla.

2 min

Can you buy a Tesla Cybertruck in Europe? Why it is not sold here, and the import question

You can buy a Cybertruck in the US, South Korea and the Middle East, but not in the EU or the UK. Here is why, and why importing one yourself is usually a dead end.

2 min

Buying a used Model S or Model X now that production has ended: what to check

A used Model S or X offers a lot of luxury for the money. Here is how the generations differ, which computer and self-driving hardware to look for, and the weak spots to inspect.

2 min

Buying a used Model 3: Highland or the original, and why HW3 vs HW4 matters

A used Model 3 can be a great deal, but the generation matters more than you might think. Here is how the original and the Highland differ, and how to check the self-driving hardware.

2 min

Model Y Juniper vs the original Model Y: every difference that matters when you buy

The refreshed Model Y looks similar from a distance but changes a lot in daily use. Here is what is new, whether the older car is still a good buy, and why accessories often don't fit both.

3 min

UK car tax from April 2026: the £50,000 'luxury car' limit for EVs, and which Teslas now escape it

From April 1, 2026, electric cars only pay the UK's expensive car supplement above a £50,000 list price. Here are the new rates, which Model 3 and Model Y versions benefit, and what to check on your own car.